Still Unsolved Still a Mystery

Mad as a Box of Frogs

"Eccentric, erratic, or wildly unpredictable."

A modern, distinctly British idiom, and one whose origin genuinely isn't known despite it being fairly recent as idioms go. The image is intuitive on its face, a box of frogs would presumably produce a chaotic scene of jumping and bouncing in every direction, but no one has traced a documented first use, a coining author, or an original context. A related, possibly earlier expression describes someone as having "a face like a box of frogs," suggesting the phrase may have started as a comment on appearance before shifting to describe erratic behaviour, but that connection itself isn't firmly established either.

Myth vs. FactThere's no shortage of guesses about where this one comes from, but nobody has produced a documented first use or original source. Treat any confident-sounding origin story for this one with real suspicion.
Sources: No confirmed first citation identified; discussed as an unresolved modern British idiom in phrase-history references including Wordhistories.net and the Cambridge Dictionary blog.

Quick react

Discuss

New comments are held for a quick check before they show up here.

Loading comments…

Back to the full repository