Still Unsolved Still a Mystery

Piece of Cake

"Something very easy to do."

The most commonly repeated theory ties this to the "cakewalk," a competitive strutting dance performed by enslaved Black Americans that mockingly imitated the formal manners of plantation owners, with a cake awarded to the winning couple. It's a compelling story, but it runs into a real problem: the earliest confirmed print use of "piece of cake" is in the British edition of Ogden Nash's 1936 book Primrose Path, where it directly replaces an earlier American phrase, "everything is jake," undermining a purely American cakewalk origin. Simpler theories, that cake is just generally easy and pleasant to eat, remain just as plausible and just as unproven.

Myth vs. FactThe cakewalk-dance theory is the one most often repeated, but its American origins sit awkwardly with the phrase's earliest confirmed appearance being in a British publication, replacing an unrelated American phrase.
Sources: Ogden Nash, Primrose Path (1936, British edition); cakewalk theory discussed and complicated in Mental Floss.

Quick react

Discuss

New comments are held for a quick check before they show up here.

Loading comments…

Back to the full repository