Popular Myths Popular Myth

Red Herring

"A misleading clue or distraction from the real issue."

The popular story is that escaping prisoners, or fox hunters trying to spoil a hunt, would drag a smelly smoked ("red") herring across their trail to throw pursuing dogs off the scent. It's a vivid image, but historians of fox hunting have found no real evidence of it being used that way. The actual source seems more mundane: a 1686 hunting manual by Nicholas Cox recommended dragging a dead cat or fox to lay an artificial scent trail for training young hunting horses and hounds, and suggested a strong-smelling red herring as a substitute if a cat or fox wasn't available. By the 19th century, that training method had been misremembered as a deliberate trick to fool the hounds, and the figurative sense of "red herring" as a deceptive distraction was born from the misunderstanding.

Myth vs. FactThe idea of a criminal or saboteur dragging a fish to fool bloodhounds is repeated constantly, but it isn't what actually happened. The real practice was a normal training exercise for hunting animals, only later reinterpreted as trickery.
Sources: Nicholas Cox, The Gentleman's Recreation (1686 hunting manual); discussed in detail by etymologist Michael Quinion (World Wide Words).

Quick react

Discuss

New comments are held for a quick check before they show up here.

Loading comments…

Back to the full repository